Compositionality: the Very Idea
نویسنده
چکیده
A. Compositionality is often considered a fundamental principle of semantics for natural language. Yet only fairly recently has there been something of a theory of compositionality which allows to prove actual results. Basically, the lack of progress has been due to an improper understanding of what syntactic and semantic structures actually are. Many linguistic theories in one way or another confuse them by importing semantic notions into syntax or—conversely—adding syntactic detail to semantic structures. In this paper I shall outline a theory of semantic and syntactic structures and show how it avoids the problems that beset the previous theories. A particular benefit of this approach is that it allows to show results on sentential structure. compositionality, syntax, semantics
منابع مشابه
Compositionality , Flexibility , and Context - Dependence
The compositionality idea is the idea that semantic interpretation proceeds in two steps. Simple expressions are interpreted by means of lexical rules, which assign meanings to them directly. Complex expressions are interpreted by means of compositional rules, which assign meanings to them indirectly, as a function of the meanings of their parts. For any simple expression , the associated lexi...
متن کاملSemantic-Driven Emergence of Syntax : The Principle of Compositionality upside-down
In Chomskyan views of linguistics, syntax is a preeminent independent level whose knowledge is mainly innate. Semantics is then usually seen as a secondary structure deduced from the syntactic analysis. The Principle of Compositionality is, in this context, a precise way of specifying the passage from syntax to semantics. But from an emergence perspective, this conception is very awkward. As a ...
متن کاملCompositionality Criteria for Defining Mixed-Styles Synchronous Languages
This is not a paper about compositionality in itself, nor a general paper about mixing synchronous languages. We rst recall that compositionality appears in three places in the deenition of synchronous languages : 1) the synchrony hypothesis guarantees that the formal semantics of the language is compositional (in the sense that there exists an appropriate congruence) ; 2) programming environme...
متن کاملBeyond Symbolic: Prolegomena to a Kama-Sutra of Compositionality1
Consider some of the obvious differences between a printed and a spoken version of the very same English sentence. Both contain the same words, but in the printed sentence they are static ink configurations, while in the utterance they are temporally extended sound patterns. In the printed case, words are combined by juxtaposition in space; in the utterance, by juxtaposition in time. The printe...
متن کاملA Tensor-based Factorization Model of Semantic Compositionality
In this paper, we present a novel method for the computation of compositionality within a distributional framework. The key idea is that compositionality is modeled as a multi-way interaction between latent factors, which are automatically constructed from corpus data. We use our method to model the composition of subject verb object triples. The method consists of two steps. First, we compute ...
متن کامل